BIg Poppa Smokers Dana Point Friday Night Dinner

Big Poppa

Administrator
OK Ill sort of take you through the mindset when cooking for a large crowd....If affects your cooking temp and your menu.

1. Keep it as simple as possible
2. If you have others bringing dishes they will delay your main meats

I grew up in Orange County and had friends show up from deep in the past...also the inlaws were there too last night. I even had my babysitter last night

So I cooked two prime new york strips in block form Seasoned them with evoo little louies with pepper and double secret. Cooked them on the MAK One Star on the shelf and had them on smoke setting for an hour then raised the temp to 220. I intentionally selected a lower cooking temp because I anticipated a delay in other peoples dishes (sis in laws taters) The reason why is that if I cooked it at 300 the residual cooking after I took it off the smoker would have made it way overdone....I pulled them at 134 and tented with foil and placed it in the Cambo (caterers cooler) It rested over two hours but was 128 when sliced. It is super important when cooking for a crowd with roasts and such taht you do not pre slice...you presentation slice. Otherwise you get meat that dries out and gets cold. Waa Laa
DSCF0181.jpg

DSCF0179.jpg

DSCF0184.jpg

Then it was a riff on the potato discs....Lets call these Poppa's Party Potatoes
I sliced them and then put a slice of sweet onion and alternated until the pan was full
I then drizzled lightly with a garlic balsamic reduction and then little louies with pepper and 3 cubes of butter and some EVOO. I cooked at 400 for an hour and a half and they came out how I had hoped Nice and soft with a crispy edge and the onions almost melted away
DSCF0175.jpg

sorry no pics of them done I had my hands full
WE had over 30 people and there wasnt anything left. I was really happy that the lady that runs Jaime Olivers cooking classes (she teaches them too) was impressed with the flavor profile of the beef (non seared) and she loved how I treated the onions and potatos.

Is was a wonderful night...simple but fed the people

Sis in Law made twice baked that came in second in the potato category....(hahahahaha)
and she brought a carrot cake. Another dear friend brought a killer homemade key lime pie
Moral of the story if you dont have total control of the dinner cook at a lower heat and the pressure is off
 

Rip

New member
Great looking food and great tips, thanks BP! Those potatoes look killer! (sorry Sis, I'm sure yours were awesome too) and WOW do those NY strips look fantastic!!

So if I make it down for Friday night at the Royal can I sneak into your dinner (if I hide behind Andy)?
 

TentHunter

Moderator
Hey, now I like that idea!

I often add onion to roasting potatoes, but alternating between slices of potato & onion to have whole slices of roasted onion? OH YEAH!!! now that had to be good. :)

I'm copying that!
 

sparky

New member
food looks great. your always a gracious cook. making sure everyone is happy. thats a good thing. your a good person BP. rip you should go. bp cooks fantastic food and brad pours great espresso drinks. there is so much knowledge just from talking to the guys. :)
 

jimsbarbecue

Moderator
Good info. Cooking for crowds can be tricky

Sent from Jim's BBQ using tapatalk

Patty calls those Johnny Trigg Potatoes
 
Last edited:

Chili Head

New member
Cooking for crowds or get togethers is one of my favorite things to do!
I don't sit and eat until everyone gets served. Then don't bother me! It's my turn LOL :D



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

SisInLaw

New member
Em, firstly my twice baked potatoes also had sauteed onions in them. Secondly, they "delayed" the dinner only because the MAK smoker was temp was set too low by others.

His New York strips were amazing, though. His potatoes were middlin'.
 

Big Poppa

Administrator
W threw away an empty pan of my potatos and yours we threw half of them away....people looked like they were trying to swallow brussel sprouts whole and the mak was set at the right temp....You potatos took one hour to "Just heat them up a little"

But once again sis misses the lesson here...Its no problem if you anticipate it and cook at a lower temp so residual cooking doesnt happen
 
Top Bottom