Need some help from the Mak 1 Star owners.

Aizen

New member
Hello,

A Mak 1 Star is my current leading candidate for a future pellet smoker purchase. I'm quite concerned about the capacity however. The main reason I'm looking at a pellet cooker is because I have physical issues that hamper me at times and during the past holiday season, tending and cleaning my current smoker was difficult and this led to a slightly diminished Christmas dinner. Still great, but not what I planned or wanted to do.

And that, it where the capacity issue rears it's head. Holiday meals around here generally involve a fair amount of food being barbecued. Average is a couple of full racks of pork spare ribs, a beef item which on big holidays is a full rack of plate short ribs but on smaller cooks may be a chuck roast or smaller short ribs, a Hillshire Farms/Smithfield type 16 ounce sausage, and a side generally in a 9 inch pie plate iE: beans or mac and cheese. Occasionally some type of potato side too. The biggest cook I've done was a 10 lb. brisket, two 5 lb pork spares, a 6 lb pork butt, two sausages, 9 inch pie plate of beans, 9 inch pie plate of mac and cheese, and some sauce is a 1.5 quart sauce pan. The beans, mac, and sauce went on after the brisket was pulled and resting.

Ultimately, what I'd like to be able to cook at once on the 1 star would be four full racks of pork spare ribs WITHOUT using a rib rack or replicate the meat combo from the previously mentioned biggest cook I've done. I plan on purchasing the full upper shelf with the unit already and have no problems doing the sides and say sausages as the large meats are resting.

So, Mak 1 Star owners, do you think this is possible or have you done cooks of similar/larger size yourselves? And do any of you have pictures of cooking St. Louis cut or spare ribs on the 1 Star? I've seen many on the 2 Star and the Mak video, but 1 Star rib pics are a bit hard to find.

Thank you.
 
Last edited:

Aizen

New member
Mods, you can probably lock this thread. I was able to find a satisfactory answer.:eek::D

I went Google image searching and stumbled across more of TentHunter's incredible pics and in them, I found this gem:

B2BPTY05.JPG


Beef back ribs in my experience are good size matches for whole pork spares and the above pic shows four racks sitting nicely with room to spare. The thread is here if anyone else is interested in TentHunter's other excellent and helpful pics.

http://www.pelletsmoking.com/pellet-smoking-com-lounge-9/yoder-vs-lousiana-7102/index2.html

The bacon smoking pic has also been quite helpful.

Thanks TentHunter!
 

Big Poppa

Administrator
tent is a mod here ad those are form the forum so no locking the beauty of the MAKs is that their full racks actually double your cooking area unlike the competition...I have neverhad a capacity issue with mine
 

onionhead

Member
Aizen, your questions/concerns are very well thought out. I have a MAK 2 & can't answer your questions, but I would wait for Tenthunter to reply. He is probably at a competition this WE, but he is a very good source of information. Good luck.
 

TentHunter

Moderator
Aizen said:
Thanks TentHunter!

You are most welcome. I'm just glad some of my previous posts were helpful!


If you get the 1 Star with either a full upper rack or two upper half racks, you will not be disappointed with capacity. I like the two upper half racks better, as it gives you more flexibility (I don't always need a full upper rack).

I can get 4 racks of Spareribs on the MAK with room to spare. If you use a rib rack you can get even more on.


Here are a couple more pics/links that may also be helpful:

Eight pork butts on the MAK at once.
PP43003.JPG



Eighty pieces of chicken.
MFOC01.JPG


Here's the full post: http://www.pelletsmoking.com/mak-central-14/how-much-chicken-can-mak-1-star-hold-7065/
 

rguynn

New member
How did those 8 butts come out? I've noticed close to the front and back edges it gets quite a bit hotter. Did you rotate them?

Sent from my SM-N910V using Tapatalk
 

TentHunter

Moderator
How did those 8 butts come out? I've noticed close to the front and back edges it gets quite a bit hotter. Did you rotate them?


Yes the front & back edges get a little hotter where the heat comes up, but I don't rotate because that's not been an issue for me on low & slow cooks. I tend to foil them after they've developed a good bark anyway.

On higher heat cooks, when I'm filling up the grill with chicken and such (like the photo above), then yes I tend to watch the ones closer to the front/back and rotate if/when needed. Even then it's not an issue because the chicken all has to be turned over anyway.

Also the chicken on the bottom usually gets done a little quicker than the chicken on the upper rack. Again, no biggie; when the chicken below is done I pull it off and move the chicken up top down to the bottom for a few more minutes on each side.

Hope this answers your question. :)
 

rguynn

New member
Yes it does. Interesting you said chicken on the bottom gets done sooner. I noticed this myself recently and I assumed it would have been reverse. . I need to measure the temp differential from top to bottom.

Sent from my SM-N910V using Tapatalk
 

Aizen

New member
Thank you all for the help and info about the 1 Star.

It looks like I'm going to have to put the purchase on the back burner for a bit but I should hopefully be able to at least put a 1 Star on layaway at BPS in the next couple of months.

I do have a few more questions to ask those with experience on the 1 Star:

1. Do you do anything in particular to help protect the powder coat? From the reading I've done, there were some small issues years ago with the outside of house powder coat Mak used to use. While I like that Mak will recoat the units under warranty, having to ship it back to them would definitely be a hassle. I'm thinking that perhaps along with keeping the 1 Star on a covered porch with the cover on when not in use, that treating the unit somewhat like a cast iron/carbon steel item may be beneficial. "Seasoning" the smoker kind of like a big offset and especially in areas where the coat comes off if it does. I'm in the high desert but we do get quite humid during the Monsoon season and wood burning and cooking give off moisture as well.

2. While I'm approaching the 1 Star with grilling being at best a tertiary concern, I would still like to grill on occasion for simple convenience. What I do plan on doing on a more frequent basis with the 1 Star is using it as an outdoor/pizza oven. So, this relates to my first question about the powder coat in a way, but for those of you who use a 1 Star at temps above 350, and more precisely, temps in the region of 425-High on a regular schedule, have you seen or had any issues with the unit? The primary reason, by a large margin, I'm looking at the Mak is as a smoker for barbecue. That's where it would get the most use but using it as an outdoor oven would be the secondary practice. Kind of giving the wood fired taste to many foods and especially to avoid heating the house in the summer.

Again, I'd like to say thank you for the help and information shared. It's been helpful.
 

TentHunter

Moderator
The only issues with the powder coat I have seen with both my original 1 Star and with the newer one, is just around the lip where the lid comes down and makes contact. I've has a few chips flake off, but that's it.

ALSO REMEMBER, MAK uses aluminized steel, so the minor flaking I have seen has not result in any rusting whatsoever on either of the 1 Stars.


The 1 Star makes an excellent pizza oven. We have a couple of 16" Pizza pans. We will either make pizzas ourselves or take our pans down to our local pizzeria and have them make us up a couple of take & bake pizzas.

We typically set the MAK for around 375°ish and bake them for about 25 - 30 min. rotating about half way through.

http://www.pelletsmoking.com/pelletsmoking-com-gallery-10/christmas-eve-pizza-mak-3238/
 

CMack1

New member
I have an older MAK one star, #131. I'm not the best at taking care of it. It sits in the so cal sun all the time. As I type this I have no idea where the cover is. She works beautifully and like tent said, there is a bit of flaking where the lid meets the body. The rest of the cooker looks new. Once every few months I scrub the ol girl with simple green and a plastic bristle brush, then hose her off. Of course I don't spray water directly at the controller, but everywhere else gets the hose. I am honestly baffled by how well this thing holds up. Still cranks right up and runs all night dead on accurate.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

TentHunter

Moderator
Just a quick note on capacity. I just did our annual Marching Band cookout for 120 kids & staff.

The MAK 1 Star had no problem holding enough pork shoulder to feed the whole crowd, with room to spare.

38+ lbs of pork shoulder (2 whole shoulders + 1 butt)
BAND2015.JPG



I got so busy cooking and serving I totally forgot to ask someone to get more pics. :rolleyes:
 
Top Bottom